Back to Game Reviews
Game Reviews
74

Hillthorn’s card mystery wins critics over, just not by a mile

Hillthorn review roundup: five scored reviews average 74 for this short, card-driven Steam mystery. Good, not great, at $14.99, with only six critics in.

On
4 min read
A dark desk with playing cards, a pocket watch and a magnifying glass

Pros

  • GameSpew: a unique detective game where dialogue and actions are replaced by a deck of cards
  • KonsoliFIN: unique gameplay mechanics and stunning visual art style
  • Pizza Fria: the narrative and atmosphere justify giving it a chance

Cons

  • Loot Level Chill: the time-loop elements start to grind rather quickly
  • KonsoliFIN: the experience feels a little too compact

Good, not great, on six reviews

The Hillthorn review scores so far add up to a 74: respectable, a little cautious, and resting on just six critics. OpenCritic’s six reviews describe a mystery told entirely through cards that critics clearly enjoy, and the highest score is 8.1 out of 10.

That 74 is our own consensus figure: the mean of the five scored reviews, each converted to a 100-point scale (80, 81, 70, 70 and 70, which averages 74.2). Gaming-Village’s unscored Recommended is left out, and OpenCritic shows no Top Critic Average for the game.

Hillthorn comes from developers Fool Moon and Finnegan Motors, is published by Raw Fury, and launched on PC on 10 November 2026. Steam calls it a dark investigation game: a child has gone missing, time is in short supply, and the mystery unfolds “without a single word spoken”. Everything is revealed through Clue cards that can be Investigated, Explored or, in some instances, Talked to.

OutletScoreTakeaway
GameSpew8/10 (80)A unique detective game built on a deck of cards
Pizza Fria8.1/10 (81)Narrative and atmosphere justify a try
Loot Level Chill7/10 (70)Compelling, but the time loop grinds
KonsoliFIN3.5/5 (70)Striking art, but a little too compact
Gameliner3.5/5 (70)Interesting, not very challenging, story not original
Gaming-VillageRecommended (unscored)Familiar thriller, powerful whole

Storytelling by cards is the draw

The praise keeps coming back to the mechanic. GameSpew calls Hillthorn “a unique investigation/detective game where dialogue and actions are replaced by a deck of cards”. Gaming-Village’s Sascha Ritter singles out the “intuitive and narratively brilliant card-based gameplay” (translated from German), and KonsoliFIN points to “unique gameplay mechanics and stunning visual art style” in Fool Moon’s debut (translated from Finnish).

Mood counts too. Pizza Fria‘s Leandro Felippe de Paiva Gomes writes, “I really enjoyed the narrative, the atmosphere, and the general ideas presented by Hillthorn” (translated from Portuguese), adding that those aspects alone justify giving the game a chance.

A contract document with a photo attached, lying on a desk
Image: Fool Moon / Raw Fury

Compact, familiar and a bit loopy

The complaints are smaller, but they’re consistent in tone. KonsoliFIN’s Petri Leskinen writes that the experience “feels a little too compact” and that the end credits left them wishing they “could have continued the story for just a little longer” (translated from Finnish). Steam itself bills the game as a “short, atmospheric mystery”. Loot Level Chill‘s Lyle Pendle finds it “very compelling” but says “the time loop elements start to grind rather quickly”.

Gaming-Village reads the same structure more kindly. It admits the adventure is “essentially ‘just’ a mystery thriller” we’ve seen before, then still lands on Recommended, even with time loops as a “pioneering structural element” (translated from German). Gameliner says it “doesn’t feature the most challenging gameplay in the world” and calls the story “not-so-original” yet still fresh (translated from Dutch). Pizza Fria warns that anyone expecting a deeper exploration of the game’s ideas “may end up disappointed”.

A black-and-white silhouette of a person at a desk beside a door
Image: Fool Moon / Raw Fury

Six reviews isn’t a consensus

Scores run from 70 to 81 on our conversion, a narrow spread, but it’s five outlets and not much to lean on. OpenCritic’s Top Critic label sits on two of the six reviews (GameSpew and Loot Level Chill), yet there’s no Top Critic Average to quote. Steam’s user reviews read Very Positive from 209 reviews at the time of writing, a different crowd measured a different way, so we wouldn’t line the two up.

Small indies often live on thin samples. Danchi Days charmed critics with only four reviews in, and Anomalith’s roundup showed how a few outlets can disagree about a small game’s finish. A couple more Hillthorn reviews could move that 74 in either direction.

Cards marked with green arrows beside a stopwatch and a magnifying glass
Image: Fool Moon / Raw Fury

Price, demo and PC requirements

Steam’s US store lists Hillthorn at $14.99, and a demo is available there. The listed minimum and recommended PC specs are the same apart from storage: Windows 10 64-bit, a dual-core 2.4 GHz processor, 4 GB of RAM and a GeForce GTX 950 or Radeon RX 570, with 1 GB of space at minimum and 2 GB recommended. The developers flag references to drugs, violence, alcohol and suicide, all shown only through the art on cards.

Who should buy it

  • Buy if a cards-only detective story with no dialogue sounds fresh to you; GameSpew, KonsoliFIN and Gaming-Village all single out the mechanic.
  • Buy if you like short, atmospheric mysteries and don’t mind finishing in a sitting or two.
  • Wait if you need a broad critical consensus; six reviews and no Top Critic Average is thin.
  • Wait if repeating loops tend to wear on you, since Loot Level Chill found they grind quickly.

Our take: buy for the premise

We think 74 is a fair summary of what’s been written so far: a well-liked idea, executed with style, that tops out at an 8.1 and gets docked for being compact and familiar. With a missing child, a mountain and a ticking clock as the hook, a $14.99 price and a demo to try first, we’d lean towards buying if the premise grabs you. If you’d rather see a wider spread of critics first, wait a few weeks; more reviews will show whether 74 holds.

Want a different kind of indie that did better with critics? Probably Stolen’s shady shop loop won most critics over.

0 comments

Join the conversation

Anyone can read comments. Sign in or create a free account to post and reply.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.