Still an easy recommendation
The first Pikmin 4 Switch 2 Edition review scores are in, and they’re generous: OpenCritic’s Top Critic Average is 83, and 93% of critics recommend it. Pikmin 4: Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy arrives on 12 November 2026 on Nintendo Switch 2. The praise is for the game underneath; the arguments are about what’s been bolted on top.
A quick note on the numbers: 83 is OpenCritic’s Top Critic Average, which draws on its Top Critics only. The 93% Critics Recommend figure is a separate measure, the site lists 15 critic reviews in total, and it ranks the game in the 91st percentile of everything it has scored. Eight of those reviews headline the page:
| Outlet | Score | Takeaway |
|---|---|---|
| Nintendo Life | 7/10 | Calls the latest long-titled Switch 2 Edition “a strange one” |
| COGconnected | 75/100 | Asks whether the extras help or the game’s “delicious fruit” has started to sour |
| Press Start | 8/10 | Big resolution boost, but a strictly time-restricted Academy |
| Metro GameCentral | 8/10 | New mode is “a serious challenge for Pikmin experts” |
| CGMagazine | 8.5/10 | “Decent add-ons to an already excellent game” |
| Video Chums | 8.6/10 | “A wonderful package” with a superb core game |
| Hobby Consolas | 87/100 | Newcomers shouldn’t hesitate (translated from Spanish) |
| The Games Machine | 9.1/10 | Highest of these eight; no excerpt available |

The Academy is the argument
Dandori Academy is the headline addition, and the reviews disagree on how much it carries. Metro GameCentral says it “adds an intriguing new mode that offers a serious challenge for Pikmin experts.” Video Chums calls it “an excellent new mode filled with unique and entertaining challenges,” and Gfinity (9/10) singles out its “brilliant weekend Dandori exams.”
The pushback is about structure. Press Start found “the bizarrely strict time-restricted nature of the Dandori Academy” may see some players “skipping school until there is more to do.” Digitec Magazine’s reviewer, who had only one weekend with it, was warmer (translated from German): they can see the six weekly challenges “feeling like mini-DLCs,” and named the new Dandori Battles, “with their chaotic items and effects,” as their highlight.

A 4K bump, but no 60 fps
Press Start called the resolution boost “very substantial,” though it also flagged “the lack of other presentation modes.” Cerealkillerz (8.7/10) made frame rate its biggest criticism: the frame rate “hasn’t been increased to 60 FPS, presumably because native 4K resolution in docked mode was prioritized instead” (translated from German). The same review still calls the package good value as an upgrade pack.
Others are happier with how it looks. Video Chums praises “lovely visuals and performance,” Gfinity cites “crisp 4K visuals,” and Digitec Magazine says the improved visuals are particularly noticeable in TV mode.

Best for anyone who missed it
The strongest endorsements are aimed at newcomers. Hobby Consolas (translated from Spanish) says that if you didn’t try Pikmin 4 back in the day, “don’t hesitate: it’s one of the most charming and addictive adventures Nintendo has created in recent years.” Loot Level Chill gave it 9.5/10 and called it “another must play, especially for those who missed it the first time around.”
We think the 83 is a fair reading of a split verdict: nobody quoted here doubts the core game, while the extras get applause or shrugs depending on how much you want a weekly, time-limited challenge. If you’re stacking up Switch 2 reading, our roundups of Ocarina of Time’s remake and Stellar Blade on Switch 2 cover two other recent releases.
- ✅ Buy if you never played Pikmin 4: Hobby Consolas and Loot Level Chill both point newcomers to it.
- ✅ Buy if you want a sharper picture on a TV: Digitec Magazine and Gfinity both single out the visuals.
- ❌ Skip if you need 60 fps: Cerealkillerz notes it hasn’t been added.
- ❌ Skip if you want an open-ended Academy: Press Start criticises its strict time restriction.


