Back to Game Reviews
Game Reviews
74 · IGN

Crimson Desert’s sea DLC is more buffet, for fans only

Crimson Desert Charting the Unknown review roundup: a 74 average from just five critics, with broad scope but seas one critic calls largely empty.

On
4 min read
An armoured warrior striking with a fiery burst in a rocky clearing in Crimson Desert

Pros

  • Wccftech: a worthy expansion for those who enjoyed the base game, thanks to a massive map expansion
  • GameBlast: an extraordinary amount of content
  • IGN Hungary: plenty of new content and nautical adventures

Cons

  • IGN: adds to the buffet-style approach while doing little to improve upon it
  • Gamersky: seas and underwater areas are vast but largely empty compared with the base game's landmass
  • IGN Hungary: still carries some of the base game's frustrating flaws

More ocean, same buffet

The first Crimson Desert Charting the Unknown reviews land on a familiar verdict: more of the same, now with a ship. OpenCritic’s Top Critic Average is 74 and 60% of critics recommend it, but only five critic reviews are in so far, so treat both numbers as a first read rather than a settled one.

IGN’s 6/10 is the cold shower: “This beefy DLC adds even more to the buffet-style approach while doing little to improve upon it.” The other four scores sit higher, from 7.5 to 8.3, and the argument between them is mostly about what “more” is worth.

OutletScoreTakeaway
IGN6/10Adds to the buffet, little improved
Wccftech8/10Worthy for fans, massive map expansion
Gamersky8.3/10Seas and underwater areas vast but largely empty
IGN Hungary8/10Lots of new content, base-game flaws remain
GameBlast7.5/10Huge amount of content, ambition gets in the way

What the $24.99 covers

Steam lists it as Crimson Desert Enhanced: Charting the Unknown, priced at US $24.99, and it requires the base game, Crimson Desert Enhanced, to play. OpenCritic gives a PC release date of October 29, 2026; the Steam page shows October 30. Steam user reviews read Mostly Positive across more than 1,200 reviews, which is a different crowd from the five critics.

The store pitch is a long list. Take command of a ship, set sail to new islands off the coast, then dive for underwater treasures, sunken ruins and hidden mysteries. Rent and manage a variety of facilities, build a home with the upgraded Housing mode, and follow new stories for Kliff, Oongka and Damiane. Pearl Abyss also promises that “formidable foes await across land and sea.”

A huge red beast charging across a dusty plain
Image: Pearl Abyss

Big seas, not much in them

The sharpest complaint comes from the review with one of the higher scores. Gamersky’s 8.3 is a Chinese-language review, and in OpenCritic’s English version it says the expansion “establishes a framework for sailing and diving” but that “the vast but largely empty seas and underwater environments fail to deliver the same sense of exploration as the rich ecosystems and varied landscapes of the Pywel continent in the base game.” The same review calls the experience “more ambitious in scope than substantial in execution.”

The Portuguese-language GameBlast review, scored 7.5, lands in a similar place in OpenCritic’s English text: the expansion “offers an extraordinary amount of content, but its own ambition prevents some of these new features from reaching their full potential.” IGN Hungary gave it an 8 for “plenty of incredible new content and exciting nautical adventures,” while noting it “still carries some of the frustrating flaws of the base game with itself.”

A blue-lit underwater view of huge chains and machinery
Image: Pearl Abyss

The most generous take belongs to Wccftech, which scored it 8 and called it “a worthy expansion to get for all those who enjoyed the base game thanks to a massive map expansion.” Notice who that sentence is addressed to. Even the warmest of the five frames the DLC as a reward for people already on board.

Critic access has been a sore spot with this game before: Crimson Desert’s boss said critics didn’t get enough time. With five reviews in, the DLC’s critical picture is still thin, and a late review could move a 74 in either direction.

Who should set sail

  • ✅ Buy if you loved the base game and want more of it: Wccftech calls the map expansion massive and the DLC worthy for people who enjoyed the original.
  • ✅ Buy if scope matters more to you than polish: GameBlast and IGN Hungary both point to a large amount of new content.
  • ❌ Skip if you bounced off the base game: IGN says the DLC does little to improve on it, and IGN Hungary says the original’s frustrating flaws remain.
  • ❌ Skip if you want the sea to feel as alive as the land: Gamersky found the seas and underwater areas vast but largely empty.
A dark-haired man in red robes holding up a parchment notice in front of stone buildings
Image: Pearl Abyss

Our take: a sequel-sized add-on, not a second chance

We think the scores tell a simple story once you read past the numbers. The DLC does what its critics say the base game does, only with more water in it, and nobody in the five reviews describes it as a fix. If the original had you hooked, $24.99 for new islands, a ship and Housing upgrades looks like fair value, and our earlier advice that the free trial is the smarter move still applies if you’re on the fence about the game itself.

If you drifted away from Crimson Desert, we wouldn’t expect this to pull you back. A 74 from five critics, with the harshest score calling it more buffet and the most enthusiastic one aimed squarely at existing fans, is a recommendation for the converted. Wait for more reviews and for the empty seas to be filled in, or skip it.

0 comments

Join the conversation

Anyone can read comments. Sign in or create a free account to post and reply.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.