Back to Game Reviews
Game Reviews
78

Probably Stolen’s shady shop loop wins most critics over

Probably Stolen reviews land at 78 on OpenCritic: most critics like the cyberpunk shopkeeper sim’s stolen-goods loop, but two low scores deserve a read.

On
4 min read
A cluttered cyberpunk shop counter seen from the shopkeeper side, with a customer at the counter and shelves behind

Pros

  • SomGeek: a brilliant shop simulator with an unforgiving loop of legitimate trading, black-market deals and paranoia over police raids
  • Niche Gamer: a strong full-price recommendation for players who enjoy trading, management and interconnected systems
  • Softpedia: a refreshing, intense and rewarding shopkeeper simulator

Cons

  • GameBlast: barely reaches break-even and lacks ideas to stand out among cyberpunk or simulation games
  • The Games Machine: less patient players may struggle with the initial complexity and repetition
  • GamesCreed: excessive busywork and restrictive saving occasionally undermine the game

Fencing goods for a living

Most Probably Stolen reviews circle the same hook: you run a shop on a cyberpunk space station, and your best margins come from goods of questionable origin. OpenCritic’s Top Critic Average is 78 and 82% of critics recommend it. The scored reviews below run from 5.5 out of 10 to 90%, so the low ones are worth reading before you commit.

Developer Questing Goose Studio and publisher tinyBuild released it on PC on 28 October 2026. The Steam page pitches a cyberpunk shopkeeping simulator on a dystopian space station where you “craft, trade, and smuggle goods of questionable origin” and decide “how far you’re willing to go to stay afloat”. The goal is to buy out your shop before rising rent forces your hand. Steam’s English user reviews sit at Overwhelmingly Positive, from more than 5,000 reviews.

On the numbers: the 78 is OpenCritic’s Top Critic Average, the 82% is the share of critics who recommend the game, and OpenCritic lists 11 critic reviews in total. These are the scores it shows most prominently.

OutletScoreTakeaway
SomGeek90%Unforgiving loop, constant paranoia
Niche Gamer8.5/10Strong full-price recommendation for system lovers
CrazyGameCommunity.it8.5/10A shop sim that truly inhabits its setting
The Games Machine8/10Freedom and systems, but a patient start
GameSpew8/10A shopkeeper’s job full of responsibilities
Softpedia8/10Refreshing, intense and rewarding
DualShockers6.5/10Easy controls, complex systems
GameBlast5.5/10Bare minimum of competence

Risk is the mechanic

Steam’s description makes trouble the product. Weapons bring inspections, chemicals bring addiction, water brings liability and contraband brings raids. You can start as a gunsmith, chemist, water merchant, fence, farmer or from absolute rock bottom, and every sale can be approved, refused, reported or looked away from.

SomGeek’s 90% is the most excited review: in OpenCritic’s English rendering of the Slovak text, it is a “brilliant cyberpunk shop simulator” with an “unforgiving gameplay loop of legitimate trading, black-market deals, and constant paranoia over unexpected police raids”. Niche Gamer gave it 8.5 and called it “a strong full-price recommendation for players who enjoy trading, management and learning interconnected systems”. Softpedia went with “refreshing, intense and rewarding”.

The moral twist lands with several outlets. CrazyGameCommunity.it (8.5) says, in the OpenCritic excerpt, that it doesn’t just wear a cyberpunk skin but inhabits it, with suspicious customers, ravenous factions and a rogue AI. PCMGAMES gave it a Recommended and says that if you’re drawn to its mix of commerce and moral choices, it’s worth a try.

A shop counter scene with an item being inspected
Image: Questing Goose Studio / tinyBuild

Where the busywork shows

Even the friendly reviews flag the grind. The Games Machine (8/10) praises a surprising number of possibilities and a remarkable degree of freedom in specialisation, then warns that less patient players might struggle with the initial complexity and the repetitive nature of the experience. GamesCreed (4.5 out of 5) calls it addictive, with excellent pixel art and meaningful decisions, but says excessive busywork and restrictive saving occasionally undermine it.

That matters for a game whose own pitch is that rent keeps rising and every purchase has to earn its keep. Steam also lists the game as single-player, and the store page asks for modest hardware: Windows 10, an Intel Core i3 or equivalent, 8 GB of RAM and a GTX 650 Ti equivalent or higher.

A document and an ID lying on the counter in front of a customer
Image: Questing Goose Studio / tinyBuild

The two low scores

GameBlast’s 5.5 is the real dissent. In the Portuguese review’s English excerpt on OpenCritic, the game barely reaches break-even, goes no further than the bare minimum of competence, and lacks the ideas to stand out either among cyberpunk games or within the simulation genre. It is the only review in the set that says the game has nothing of its own to add.

The DualShockers 6.5 is odder. The excerpt OpenCritic shows calls the game “fairly impressive”, with “easy-to-understand controls yet complex system” that sets players up to play for hours, so the number reads lower than the words. We’d read that full review before dismissing it.

Gloves and a hand-shaped item being examined on the counter
Image: Questing Goose Studio / tinyBuild

Our take

We think the split is about appetite for systems. The praise is for freedom, tension and a loop that keeps you opening the shop for one more day, while the complaints are repetition, busywork and a lack of fresh ideas. If learning interconnected trading rules sounds like fun, the 78 undersells it. Critics rated Psycho-Sleuth on its cast rather than its systems; Probably Stolen is mostly being judged on the systems.

  • ✅ Buy if you enjoy trading and management games and like working out how every item, customer and faction fits together.
  • ✅ Buy if you want a shop sim where selling stolen goods, bribes and raids are part of the loop.
  • ❌ Skip if repetition and busywork put you off, as they did for The Games Machine and GamesCreed.
  • ❌ Skip if you want a game with its own big ideas; GameBlast found none.

For other recent critic splits, see our Queen’s Domain roundup and the Warhammer Survivors roundup. If you’re on the fence here, read GameBlast and GamesCreed first and ask whether busywork bothers you. If it doesn’t, this is an easy yes.

0 comments

Join the conversation

Anyone can read comments. Sign in or create a free account to post and reply.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.